I Explain: How Fee Schedules Really Work
Key Takeaways
- A payer fee schedule is not a simple price list; it is a three-layer construct consisting of a benchmark, an adjustment, and carve-out exceptions.
- The headline percentage rate in a contract is meaningless without verifying the underlying base year, Medicare locality, and clinical setting.
- Payers often control costs quietly by freezing the base year to an older Medicare fee schedule rather than using current rates.
- High-volume codes are frequently carved out and paid off different schedules or flat rates, which can significantly reduce a practice's effective reimbursement rate.
- Practices must pull their top 20 CPT codes by volume and normalize their contract rates to a percentage of current Medicare in order to accurately compare payers.
I assert the central lesson: read your payer contract like a payer negotiator. I explain that a fee schedule is not a simple price list but a three‑layer construct composed of a benchmark, an adjustment, and carve‑out exceptions.
We must identify the benchmark year, the correct Medicare locality, and the appropriate setting because the headline percentage is meaningless without them. I show that many high‑volume codes are carved out and paid off different schedules or flat rates, which can reduce your effective rate. I instruct you to convert your top 20 CPT codes to percent of current Medicare, payer by payer, so all contracts sit on the same scale.
We cannot negotiate what we cannot measure, and clarity on these points is the prerequisite to any successful discussion with payers.
Takeaways:
- I explain that payer fee schedules start from a Medicare benchmark, are adjusted, and include carve outs.
- We must verify which Medicare year, which locality, and which clinical setting the contract references to see true payment levels.
- I advise converting your top practice CPT codes into percent of current Medicare across payers to make an accurate comparison.
- We find that headline percentage rates can be misleading when base years are frozen or when code exhibits reduce effective payment.
- I recommend pulling the top twenty CPT codes by visit volume, writing contract rates using the correct base year, locality, and setting, then normalizing to current Medicare percentages.
Companies mentioned in this episode:
- Humana
- Carenodes
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a fee schedule in healthcare contracting?
A fee schedule is a complete listing of fees used by health plans to pay doctors or providers. It is typically built in three layers: a Medicare benchmark, an adjustment percentage, and specific carve-out exceptions.
How do payers use frozen base years to control costs?
Payers can peg a contract to an older Medicare fee schedule—such as from five years prior—which prevents your rates from automatically updating and often pays significantly less than current schedules.
Why should I convert my top CPT codes to a percentage of current Medicare?
Converting your top volume CPT codes into a percentage of current Medicare puts all of your payer contracts on the same standardized scale, allowing you to accurately determine which payers are actually paying the best.
When I sat on the health plan side of the table, the first thing I learned is that providers think a fee schedule is a price list, that somebody sat at the health plan, typed in some numbers and that's where you get paid.
Speaker AVoila.
Speaker ABut that's not how it works.
Speaker AYour fee schedule is built, it starts from a benchmark, it gets adjusted and then it gets carved up with exceptions.
Speaker AIf you don't understand how it was built, you really can't tell whether one, you're being paid fairly and two definitely can't negotiate.
Speaker AI'm Alex Harijanian and I ran network negotiations for Humanis West Territories and today my company Carenodes does payer contracting for provider groups across the country.
Speaker AThis is lesson one of Read your payer contract like a payer negotiator.
Speaker AA quick note before we start this.
Speaker AThis is education, not legal advice.
Speaker ABefore you sign, amend or terminate a contract, talk to health care counsel.
Speaker AAlmost every commercial or Medicare Advantage fee schedule you'll see is built in three layers.
Speaker ALayer one is the benchmark for professional services.
Speaker AThat's usually the Medicare physician fee schedule.
Speaker AThe payer doesn't invent a price for a 99214.
Speaker AThey start from what Medicare pays.
Speaker ALayer two is the adjustment.
Speaker AThat's the percentage in your contract Payor will reimburse at 110% of the Medicare fee schedule.
Speaker AThat's the number everybody focuses on.
Speaker ALayer three is the exceptions.
Speaker ACarve outs code specific rates.
Speaker AServices paid off a different schedule entirely.
Speaker AThis is the layer most practices never read and it's often where the money is.
Speaker ALet's take each one.
Speaker AStart with the benchmark because percent of Medicare hides three questions.
Speaker AFirst, which year?
Speaker ASome contracts say the current Medicare fee schedule, which means your rates move every time Medicare updates.
Speaker AOthers peg you to a specific year.
Speaker AIf your contract says the 2021 Medicare fee schedule, you've been paid off a five year old benchmark and nobody had to renegotiate anything for that to happen.
Speaker AFreezing the base year is one of the quietest ways a payer controls cost.
Speaker ASecond, which locality?
Speaker AMedicare pays differently by geography.
Speaker AYour contract should point to the locality where you actually practice.
Speaker AIf it's silent, ask what the payer uses.
Speaker AThird, which setting?
Speaker AMedicare pays a different rate for many services depending on whether they're done in a facility or a non fac setting like your office.
Speaker AMake sure the contract and your billing agree on which one applies.
Speaker AThe percentage is real, but it's only meaningful once you know the benchmark under it, right?
Speaker ASo when you see 120% of an old frozen schedule that can pay less than 105% of the current one.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ASo when a payer offers you a higher percentage, the first thing I ask is percentage of what?
Speaker AAnd what are the exceptions?
Speaker ASo I'd be looking for language like except as set forth below in exhibit A or B or services will be reimbursed at this amount.
Speaker AWhere you'll find carve outs.
Speaker AThis is where you'll find things like this.
Speaker ALab injectables or DME paid off a different schedule.
Speaker ACodes with no medicare value paid at a percentage of billed charges or at the payer's discretion.
Speaker ASpecific codes paid at a flat rate that may be well below the headline percentage.
Speaker AIf one of your high volume codes sits in that exhibit, man, your effective rate might be nothing like that number on page one.
Speaker ASo how do you see all this clearly?
Speaker AWell, you have to convert your contract into numbers you can check for most.
Speaker AAnd how do you know whether your codes are in there?
Speaker AWell, you need to take a look at that contract, right, because it could have been signed way before your time.
Speaker AIt could have been, you know, amended and re amended.
Speaker ASo it's really important that you're able to make sure your high volume codes do not sit in that exhibit that pays less than the headline.
Speaker AContract number three moves to see your real rates.
Speaker AMove one, pull your top 20 CPT codes by volume for the last 12 months, not by charges by volume.
Speaker AThese are the codes that drive your revenue.
Speaker AMove 2.
Speaker AFor each payer, write down what the contract says you should be paid for each of those codes using the right base year, locality and setting.
Speaker AMove three, divide each payer's rate by the current Medicare rate for the same code.
Speaker ANow, every payer is expressed in the same unit, percent of current medicare.
Speaker AOkay, so here's an illustrative example.
Speaker AI'm going to make these numbers up, but it's a good example.
Speaker ASay payer A comes out around 115% of current Medicare across your top codes.
Speaker APayor B around 102%.
Speaker AAnd payer C looks like 120% on paper.
Speaker ABut it's pegged to an old base year, so it's really closer to 100% today.
Speaker AThat's the insight.
Speaker AThe payer you thought paid best might be the one paying least.
Speaker AAnd you can't see it until you put everything on the same scale.
Speaker ALet me tell you what this looked like from my old seat when a provider came to me asking for more money.
Speaker APlease give me a raise, please, I need an increase and really couldn't tell me where they even stood relative to Medicare or relative to my other contracts at the health plan.
Speaker AIt was so easy to say no.
Speaker AWhen they come in with their codes, with their network analysis, their current rates as percentage and a clear comparison, the conversation starts to change.
Speaker AThat shows me that they know their business and that they know their contract better than most people.
Speaker AThat's the lesson I'm going to give you.
Speaker ANot a negotiation yet.
Speaker AJust clarity.
Speaker ARemember, you can't negotiate what you can't measure.
Speaker AThe free worksheet for this lesson walks you through converting your top 20 notes into percent of Medicare, payer by payer.
Speaker AThe link is in the description.
Speaker AIn lesson two, we were going past the rate to the clauses that quietly cost practices money, often more than the rate itself.
Speaker AI'm Alex Yarajanian.
Speaker AThis is the Value Based Care Advisory Podcast.
Speaker ASee you in lesson two.
Speaker BA new documentary about Elizabeth.
Speaker CHolmes just opened in theaters.
Speaker CSo could a lab company walk in with that pitch and get a payer contract?
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
YouTube
Amazon Music
iHeartRadio
Pandora
Goodpods
Castbox
PlayerFM
Podchaser
Audible
Podcast Addict
Deezer
JioSaavn
Youtube Music
PocketCasts
RSS Feed